If the claims of those behind the Recloaking Papatūānuku project, officially launched yesterday by Pure Advantage and Tāne’s Tree Trust, are accurate it could be a game-changer – not only in New Zealand’s journey to net zero but in restoring biodiversity, protecting and improving the country’s waterways and soils, and firming up erosion prone lands.

Pure Advantage chair Rob Morrison said research had shown the initiative could capture 1500 million tonnes of CO2 between 2024 – 2100. That’s equivalent to about 20 years worth of New Zealand’s current emissions.

He said that was likely to be in excess of what’s needed to meet the country’s Nationally Determined Contribution, with the possibility that the surplus could be sold into international carbon markets.

Carbon for $32 a tonne

The average abatement cost of those savings would be an estimated $32 per tonne of CO2 – significantly lower than the $60 cost, projected by Treasury, of offsetting New Zealand’s emissions offshore.

Treasury estimates meeting the country’s NDC will cost in the range of $3 – $24 billion between now and 2030. (The massive spread is due to uncertainty around the size of greenhouse gas reductions that will be achieved and the cost of offsetting offshore.)

By way of comparison the estimated cost of Recloaking Papatūānuku is $8.5 – $12.1 billion by 2050.

With planting proposed to begin next year at the earliest, few if any of the carbon credits will be generated in time to meet the country’s first NDC obligations due in 2030. (The restoration side of the project could conceivably generate some verifiable credits.)

But in planetary terms the COP deadlines are somewhat arbitrary and, while the country will be left with an initial bill, it could be on track to recoup some of those losses in the future.

Morrison said New Zealand had made legally binding commitments and that walking away from them wasn’t an option. “No country in the world relies on its green credentials as much as New Zealand.”

A partnership between Iwi, farmers, communities and government

Recloaking Papatūānuku would need to build a partnership between, Iwi, businesses, farmers, communities and the government. It was a science-based approach with a Maori values system, Morrison said.

It was true that it would require a big upfront investment by government but $12 billion was less than the $14 billion in damage caused by Cyclone Gabrielle – or about twice what the country spends on roads each year. 

He said the project would help New Zealand meet its international commitments out to 2050, create jobs in the regions, and restore biodiversity, but most importantly it would give hope to our children and their children.

Morrison, a former investment banker, said he was yet to see a better proposal for dealing with New Zealand’s climate obligations. “It’s always easy to say no to a business opportunity or a visionary plan. But if you are going to say no, what’s your alternative?”

“We have an incredible opportunity to embrace the benefits of Recloaking Papatūānuku and position Aotearoa as a world-leader. This can be an intergenerational legacy for future generations and all living things. This is a long-term programme that needs immediate action,” Morrison said.

“For now, Recloaking Papatūānuku is an idea that has been thoroughly researched and analysed by some of the brightest minds in the country. It’s a seed that needs to be cared for and nurtured into a mighty kauri. The new government has an opportunity to embrace it and make it part of their lasting legacy, leading Aotearoa to a brighter future.”

He said it was concerning that the incoming ministers for climate and the environment were outside Cabinet but he hoped the new Government would see the proposal made not just good environmental sense but economic sense too.

How to pay for it?

Pure Advantage’s preferred funding mechanism would see the project paid for with repurposed NDC contributions and private funding in exchange for carbon credits with landowners receiving an annual incentive to support land use change.

Pure Advantage executive director Simon Millar said there were a number of reasons the ETS alone couldn’t deliver a programme like Recloaking Papatūānuku on its own:

• Much of the Recloaking Papatūānuku reductions are long-term, continuing long after current ETS sectors need to be at near zero emissions. Only relying on the current ETS buyers offsetting their emissions to pay for Recloaking Papatūānuku is not a sustainable funding model.
• Recloaking Papatūānuku would introduce a large number of credits into the ETS, causing a larger oversupply of NZUs (with associated negative price impacts).
• Introducing this large number of credits would not support the ETS’s role as a mechanism to reduce gross emissions: emitters would offset instead of reduce their emissions.
• The ETS is currently set up to deliver our domestic budgets, not the more ambitious Paris NDC – the additional reductions or removals to meet current and future NDCs are needed on top of what the ETS delivers.
• Because of all this, while there may well be a role for private investors, it will need to be outside/alongside the ETS.
• Limiting the amount of new pine plantations entering the ETS (which should lead to a somewhat higher ETS price) would mean additional ETS auction proceeds. some of which could help fund Recloaking Papatūānuku. Limiting forestry in the ETS to certain land classes was part of the National and NZ First manifesto.

Rob Morrison said Recloaking Papatūānuku had the potential to be a model for the world of how to successfully restore indigenous forests. “It could be New Zealand’s greatest ever export.”

A beautiful idea: Dame Anne Salmond

Dame Anne Salmond, just back from a trip to Tairāwhiti, said the floods over the weekend had underlined the urgency of doing something to stabilise the erosion prone region.

“People are wondering whether there is a viable future for them,” she said.

Research had shown that indigenous forests were ten times better at farm land and five times better than pine plantations at avoiding erosion.

“Rather than weeping at the wailing wall of climate change we need to do something about it. Recloaking Papatūānuku will allow us to stand tall in the world.

“It’s a beautiful idea and one we can work on together. Our country desperately needs this sort of project: One that unites us and gives us a sense of a plan.”

Emeritus Professor David Norton said interest and support around the country from conservation groups, farmers and iwi was huge.

“Recloaking Papatūānuku is going to be phenomenal. Farming communities are ready for this – they just need the support.”

He said Banks Peninsula – which has had a successful pest eradication programme – was a good example of a region with farms that had land suitable for returning to native forests.

Rangi Ahipene, the chair of a central North Island land trust, said many Maori landowners wanted to move away from planting pine but had no choice. “It’s the only shop in town.”

Recloaking Papatūānuku would provide an opportunity for Maori landowners to reconnect a “Tāne our Tipuna.”

Ahipene said the trust he chairs has several thousand hectares of land split between farm, pine plantation and some indigenous forests – including three dairy units.

One of those dairy units is uneconomic and Recloaking Papatūānuku could see it returned to native forests. The alternative could be the trust having to sell the whenua. 

ETS promotes short-term thinking

The Recloaking Papatūānuku briefing documents argue that the ETS promotes short-term thinking that fails to recognise the superior long-term carbon yields and biodiversity benefits of indigenous forests.

“The ETS also fails to account for the risks and liabilities associated with short lived exotic tree monocultures beyond 50-years. These risks and liabilities are effectively being “kicked down the road” for future generations in Aotearoa to deal with. This is not the legacy we should be leaving our children and grandchildren.”

The initiative is being presented to the world at the UN Climate Change Conference (COP28) 2023 in Dubai early next month.