Editor’s Note: While ComixLaunch has almost exclusively focused on the Kickstarter platform, it is not the only game in town. Indiegogo is a crowdfunding platform that hundreds of comic creators have chosen to fund their projects.
In this guest post, Jen Finelli makes the case for Indiegogo, and while ComixLaunch stands by Kickstarter as the #1 platform comic creators should master to fund their creative projects, we appreciate hearing alternative views and are happy to share them with you here.
When you hear “crowd funding,” you think Kickstarter.
Comics creatives, however, might want to think again.
Indiegogo gets a bad rap in the general numbers game out there, which I’m sure you’ve discovered from some careful googling yourself.
(You DID compare success rates before picking your platform, right?)
However, most of those statistics don’t show you data specific to comics. A la Han Solo, I had a bad feeling about this, so after hours scrolling through Indiegogo’s archives to crunch numbers, I interrogated John T. Trigonis.
John–or “Trig,” as folks in the Indiegogo neighborhood call him–is a comic creator and crowd funding expert who’s worked on thousands of dollars worth of campaigns, with his top solo campaigns grossing up to $67,000.
His personal campaign for noir comic Siren’s Calling raised more than double its goal and continues to bring in funds for him long after through Indiegogo’s InDemand option. You may know him best through the some of crowdfunding projects he’s strategized behind: projects like Iron Sky, VGHS Season 3, Super Troopers 2, Gosnell Movie, Wong Fu Productions’ First Feature Film, and a number of other big films, games, apps, and of course, comics.
Comics projects have some unique advantages on both major crowdfunding platforms, I discovered: our “full funding” rate bounces between 47 and 51 percent depending on how you count things (more specifics later). That’s WAY better than the averages floating out there on the internet for general crowdfunding, which hop around the tens and teens. Why do comic creators rock so much?
Trig attributed our success to the tight-knit nature of the comics community. It might also have something to do with the fact that we ask for more reasonable sums of money than most projects, with the plurality of successful comics projects hovering between $1K and $10K. We’re not greedy. We’re real creators. We’re rebellious, counter-cultural, and we’re stubborn: we all want to ride with our comics for the long haul.
And that’s actually part of what makes Indiegogo so attractive for comics-specific crowdfunding: its software is intrinsically built for the stubborn long haul and the small community dynamic. What am I talking about? InDemand and referral incentives.
For that stubborn long haul: InDemand
“InDemand” means that once a comic reaches its goal, the creator can keep the page up on Indiegogo forever actually collecting funds, like a store. He or she can continue to have competitions, CyberMonday sales, holiday specials, and so on, all without the work of setting up a new store, redirecting audience TO said store, and learning everything there is to know about marketing to promote said store. Store, store, store.
“Comics creators tend to not understand e-commerce,” Trig told me, and why should we? We want to spend time drawing, not selling, which makes InDemand a particularly impressive option for first time crowdfunders who want to build a long-term, faithful audience.
And it’s first-timers who need that kind of support.
On Kickstarter, the top comic project brought in over one million dollars, with 72 projects over 100K, and 1072 projects between 10K and 100K.
These winning crowdfunders were predominantly webcomics artists who’ve spent five to ten years or more daily developing their audience–people who would’ve been wildly successful on any platform.
There’s no denying that Indiegogo does attract some big names–DC comics ran a charity event that brought home more than 100K, and Alternacomics could almost call the platform home–but scrolling through the top Kickstarters vs. scrolling through the top Indiegogos offers two very different pictures (and I’ll give you the numbers on them in a second). Indiegogo definitely seem more dominated by the newcomers, and newcomers need that easier transition into long-term sales that InDemand provides.
Mobilizing Community Through Referral Rewards
IndieGogo also appeals to the uniquely tight-knit community aspect of comics by allowing creators to set up referral programs.
“Kickstarter discourages this kind of thing,” says Trig, and it’s not built into their software. On Indiegogo fans can recruit their friends and log, in the platform, how much income they’ve generated for a project. Creators can offer a special reward tier for generating $X in referrals, which builds hype and engages lower-income fans who would still like to try their hand at winning a cool prize. With that kind of power in the hands of fans, new creators can maximize the potential of much smaller communities.
Supplementing this referral option, Indiegogo also offers the ability to set up “secret perks”–perks no one can see unless they click a link to a page you create. “They can use that to incentivize previous Kickstarter backers to move over to Indiegogo, or to e-mail a thank-you, or they can send a secret perk link to just a sub-set of their backers,” says Trig.
You can imagine how powerful secret perks could be when coupled to referral software, especially in the comics community. Comics-lovers, we like stories and excitement. We run in small groups, and we like to fight over stuff. So imagine I’m crowd funding for Becoming Hero (http://byjenfinelli.com/becoming-hero-superhero-kills-his-author/), my comic-within-a-novel about a comic book character who decides to kill his author. I can tell my IRL friends that if they’ll agree to wear a sticker about Becoming Hero (the sticker thing’s been done before, to great success), I’ll give them early access to a secret perk no one else can have. I say “early access,” and then halfway through the campaign, when fever starts to die down again, I can now build hype by unlocking that secret perk for everyone who refers someone to the campaign. Or, I can offer the secret perk to everyone who donates, as a thank-you AND an incentive to get them to give more. I can create referral teams to “fight” each other based on the theme of my comic, I can set up games to play, contests, narratives–and all with a relatively small fan base that can then grow.
Show Me The Numbers
So here’s the question: do all those cool tools bring results?
That’s what I wanted to know, so I started counting.
First off, Kickstarter has WAY more comics projects archived online than Indiegogo does: we’re talking 8741 vs 902. Having the name recognition helps Kickstarter a lot. On the surface, that name recognition seems to help creators, too: out of 8741 total comics projects, 4482 reached full funding on Kickstarter, while out of 902 comic Indiegogos, 420 reached full funding. That puts Kickstarter at a 51% success rate, and Indiegogo at a 47% success rate.
This isn’t a real picture of what’s happening, though, for several reasons.
47% >/= 51%, Reason One: Flexible Funding Is Weird
First, when we estimate success like this, we fail to take into account the difference between the flexible funding and fixed funding models. (As you know, Kickstarter only offers fixed; Indiegogo offers both) Conventional wisdom now says fixed funding campaigns always have a higher chance of reaching their funding goal because of all-or-nothing stress you put on your audience.
Our 47% doesn’t factor in that difference between flexible and fixed campaigns, and the vast majority of the successful comics crowd funded through Indiegogo used flexible funding.
This surprised me: I expected to see a clear trend where successful Indiegogos used fixed funding, and unsuccessful Indiegogos used flexible funding. That’s just not the reality out there, and you’re free to scroll through 900+ crowdfunds yourself to check. For whatever reason, the flexible funding model seems to be more successful for comics than it is for the general crowdfunder: as I’m sure your Google Fu will tell you, there’s usually something like a two-to-three fold difference in success between fixed and flexible campaigns.
Why would comics do so well with flexible funding? Trig said something during our interview that I think sheds some light:
“That depends on how you define success,” he said, when I told him about the success rates I’d found. “I define it by whether or not the project gets made.”
In other words, a comic that got 75% funded, and still delivered a product, is successful, even if the creator had to take home a little less money than she hoped. You can have a good comic run for $2000, and you can have a good comic run for $25,000: the same can’t be said about bikes, coffee makers, and even sometimes films. That might be why flexible funding doesn’t seem to be hurting comics the way it apparently hurts crowdfunding in general.
So with this knowledge, I went back through my math hell and included the last 28 projects that had gained between 75% and 100% of their funding with flexible funding, allowing them to create a comic.
Note that there were 420 comics 100% or more funded, and only 28 comics between 75% and 100% funded: that means that once you pass 75%, you’re almost 15 times more likely to get full funding than you are to stop there. Furthermore, there were 449 comics above 75%, and only 234 between 25 and 75% funded: in other words, once you pass that first quarter mark, you’re two times more likely to reach your goal than to fail.
This more precise analysis comes out to a 50% success rate.
50% >/= 51%, Reason Two: InDemand Is Amazing
One thing I couldn’t mathematically take into account–because I’m not smart enough–is the impact of InDemand. I already told you that Kickstarter’s plethora of well-known webcomics artists means it nets more big-money projects, but I didn’t break it down for you with a good Indiegogo percentages comparison. I’m going to do that now.
When you play the percentages, both platforms have the bulk of their comics successes between 1K and 10K: 65% for Indiegogo, and 64% for Kickstarter. Both platforms have a very small percentage of successes in the upper echelons of 100K to one mil: 1.1% for Indiegogo, and 1.6% for Kickstarter. Not much difference here.
The big differences in funds are in the lowest low, and the moderately high funding ranges, and that’s where all those well-known webcomic artists sit.
On Kickstarter, 24.6% of their successful projects make between 10K and 100K. On Indiegogo, that’s halved: 12%. On Indiegogo, 22% of comics crowdfunders set and reached a goal of less than 1K. On Kickstarter, only 13.2% of successful projects ask for less than 1K.
In other words, the folks who generally ask for less–the little guys–make up a larger portion of the success stories on IndieGogo. And, as we established above, it’s the little guys who need InDemand to help build a continuing audience post-crowdfunding, and I don’t know how to calculate the wonderful financial boost of continuously adding funds over time. I can tell you this: I’m sure it makes up that one percent difference.
50% > 51%, Reason Three: Kickstarter Picks Winners
“But Jen,” you say.
“Hey, how did you know my name?” I say. “I didn’t mention it at the beginning.”
“Look, Jen, I’m psychic,” you say. “And I need every percentage point I can get. That last one percent makes a big difference to me.”
To which I say: you know what created that one percentage point?
Artificial picking and choosing by Kickstarter, while Indiegogo plays the nice guy. The nice guy mathematically always finishes last.
What do I mean by this?
Kickstarter is known for having stricter rules about what you can and cannot crowdfund on their site. Your Gramma cannot fundraise for her mission trip to the homeless guy down the street on Kickstarter. She can do that on Indiegogo. Kickstarter’s success rate is artificially driven through the roof by its policy of keeping out the undesirables, and Indiegogo’s rate is driven down by its willingness to let a bunch of kids ask for money to get to Comiccon. When you go through the failed “comics” projects on Indiegogo, many of them aren’t real comics projects at all. They’re people asking for stuff I don’t really understand, like trips, or comedy-related “just give me money to start my career,” or…I dunno, was that a doily? I really don’t know. It’s in the comics category, so to be honest and fair and not be mean to Kickstarter, I didn’t weed out what I didn’t understand (Indiegogo didn’t). But they’re bringing the average down.
Which is a wonderful thing, because, you see, Indiegogo doesn’t think it’s better than you. Indiegogo doesn’t believe in a right to tell you what you can and cannot dream about.
“We allow everybody to be a star,” says Trig. “And it’s just about how hard you’re willing to work to be that star.”
The Kickstarter staff personally choose what campaigns show up on the front page of Kickstarter. Meanwhile, the Indiegogo front page is determined by an algorithm that factors in the number of people who pitched in to a project, and the speed at which a project is growing, so the day I did my digging, they had a $140 campaign highlighted next to a $26,000 campaign. There’s no human picking and choosing of the winners.
There’s no superiority complex, no gatekeeper. The indie spirit is real here, you guys.
And that’s ultimately what bottom lines it for me.
No, it’s not the cool tools like InDemand, referral software, and secret prizes, and no, it’s not the fact that it’s AWESOME to have less competition (902 vs 8741 total projects is a very big difference when you’re vying for that spot on the front page).
It’s the fact that when I sign up for Indiegogo, I’m a free agent. Indiegogo doesn’t tell me whether or not I can offer perks over $10,000 (which I’d never do, but hey, crowdfunds doing industrial good might want that (http://sustainablekits.com/why-indiegogo/).
Indiegogo doesn’t make my life difficult, or ask me too many questions if I’m not American (https://beyourownbankbook.wordpress.com/2014/12/16/why-i-chose-indiegogo-over-kickstarter-to-crowdfund-byob/ ).
(Except when I’m trying to calculate success rates, in which case, holy crap Indiegogo, could you please list a total count of projects at the top of each search category because oh my gosh please?)
With Indiegogo, I can taste the smaller company mindset, and feel that direct access to peeps like Trig, even if I’m not a huge important comics person. As some other guy said (https://medium.com/en-route-to-saenthood/en-route-to-saenthood-e1a805712eaa#.j2ybqqnzd), over at Indiegogo, they’re hungry.
And that makes me hungry, too.
So tell me. What platform will you pick for your crowdfunding campaign?
Hi there! I’m Jen Finelli! I’m a world-traveling scifi author, and I wrote that guest post up there! This whole article came about because Tyler over here at ComixLaunch is a real hooman who actually corresponds with the peeps on his e-mail list. I filled out a survey recently on his website, and rather than just using that data for himself, Tyler contacted me about it personally.
I thought that was really cool. In this world of fakery and weird online advertising, I really like peeps who are real, and if you like real, too, you can sign up for Tyler’s e-mail list here to get more crowdfunding comics tips in your inbox.
If you think I’m okay, too, you can find out more about me and my whacky scifi on my website, byjenfinelli.com, and if you’d like to hear more about that comic book character who shoots his author, you can hit me up at http://becominghero.ninja/.
Happy crowdfunding, lovely people!
Warning: This Is Cyber Criminals’ New Method of Attack
You rely on Crowdability to bring you the best start-up deals. Now rely on us to bring you the most fascinating stories and trends from the world of technology. You won’t find this stuff in the mainstream press. Look for it every Friday morning.
Would You Live in This 3D-Printed Apartment?
The real estate market is crazy right now, so it can be challenging to find a new spot. But here’s a listing that’s hot off the presses — literally. Check it out here »
Beautiful Drive-In Restaurants Are Coming To Your Town
In the wake of the coronavirus, restaurants are gearing up for a drive-thru revolution. Here’s what’s in store at your favorite fast-food joint »
Your Chance to Work with Elon Musk
Elon Musk is willing to give you a job. But before you’re hired, you’ll have to solve his favorite riddle. Give it a shot »
NASA Just Dropped the Hottest Album
In space, nobody can hear you scream. But as it turns out, the cosmos are full of sounds that’ll send a chill down your spine. We’ve got your perfect Halloween soundtrack right here »
Warning: This Is Cyber Criminals’ New Method of Attack
Scammers are masquerading as big-name companies like Amazon, USPS, and Netflix — and they’re after you. Find out what you can do to stop them »
Friday Charts: I Double Dare You To Ignore This Trend
It’s Friday in the Trend Trader Daily Nation…
And that means it’s time to embrace the adage that a picture is worth a thousand words.
Each Friday, I’ll be showing you a simple chart to convey an important investment insight.
With one quick glance, you’ll be up to speed — and more importantly, you’ll be poised to profit.
This week, I’m picking up where we left off yesterday. I’ll be revealing a major trend taking shape in the semiconductor sector that every investor (this means you!) should be paying attention to.
Plus, I’ll share one of my favorite ways to profit from it.
So let’s get to it…
Sorry Pessimists, But This Chart Proves The Chip Boom Is Back
Nearly every indicator in the markets is heading south this week, but not this one:
The three-month growth in semiconductor equipment shipments.
This is the equipment required to make more chips. It’s at the front of the value and supply chains, and therefore, it represents the first small step required to bring about big growth.
To see what I mean, look what’s happening to the red line at the far right of this chart…
As you can see, semiconductor equipment shipments are soaring, and this surge points to boom times ahead. For chips, and for chip stocks.
A Lasting (Positive) Impact on Semiconductor Demand
And I’m all the more convinced of it after reading McKinsey & Company’s latest market analysis.
In short, the world’s most trusted consultancy expects the increase in working, studying, and communicating from home to have “a lasting [positive] impact on semiconductor demand and open new possibilities for existing products and services.”
McKinsey believes demand will increase for chips that “enable servers, connectivity, and cloud usage as online collaboration grows”…
And it believes demand will vastly increase for chips that power the technologies required to facilitate the paradigm shift in consumer behavior in a post-Covid world.
Prepare for a Profit Bonanza
This paradigm shift includes contactless solutions, which I’ve written about before…
And it includes home sensors, automated-delivery solutions, and digitizing lagging sectors such as healthcare, government, and defense.
Or as Clark Tseng, director of Industry Research and Statistics at SEMI said, “With the pandemic accelerating digitization to transform businesses and their delivery of services worldwide, we expect continued growth over the next two years.”
Translation: Prepare for a profit bonanza!
In fact, the last time this market indicator started spiking higher, back in early 2009, most chip equipment stocks doubled within a year.
That includes one of my favorites, Lam Research Corporation (LRCX), which I’ve written about before. (Hint, hint).
I double dare you to ignore this trend and miss out on the profit opportunity again.
P.S. Do you have a favorite chart or indicator you’d like me to analyze in upcoming Friday editions? If so, fire up the Pat Benatar and “hit us with your best shot” by replying directly to this email.
Ahead of the tape,
The Truth Behind 200,000% Returns
Historically, investing in private startups has helped investors earn astronomical returns.
For instance, Facebook’s first private investor made 200,000% when it eventually IPO’d. That’s enough to turn $1,000 into $2 million — with just one investment!
But not all private deals will be so successful. And furthermore, such investments come with a number of risks and pitfalls.
Which is why, today, I’m going to tell you the truth about investing in private companies, including all their downsides.
But even more importantly, I’ll begin to explain how to overcome these downsides…
So you can put yourself in position to earn big, fast profits!
3 Private Market Pitfalls
Yesterday, Matt explained why private startups could be considered the “perfect investment.”
After all, with just a small amount of capital, such investments can provide massive upside.
However, investing in the private markets has its own set of challenges. As Matt admitted, “there’s no such thing as a free lunch.”
So today, I’ll explain three of the biggest private market pitfalls.
Pitfall #1 — The Need to Build a Portfolio
When you invest in an early-stage private company, you’re getting in at the ground floor.
This puts you in position to pocket big upside — but it also creates investment risk.
After all, an early-stage company doesn’t generally have much revenue, its team is small, and the market for its product could still be unproven.
Some of these startups will work out, and a few will work out incredibly well — but many won’t even survive. That’s why investors need to build a portfolio of these investments.
Bottom line: investors who aren’t inclined to make the effort to build a portfolio of startup deals are taking too much risk.
Pitfall #2 — The Need for Time
Another big drawback with private investments is that the profits can take time to arrive.
Sure, Matt and I have helped our readers get into deals that delivered big returns, fast — deals like Elio Motors that handed investors 300% returns in just 30 days.
But most profits take far longer to arrive. For example, Facebook’s first investor had to wait about seven years to cash out of his investment.
So if you’re planning to retire soon, or you’re already retired, you might not have time to wait.
Pitfall #3 — Startup Investments Are Illiquid
And finally, in the private market, you can’t cash out your investments whenever you’d like.
You see, private companies don’t trade on the stock market. Generally speaking, you won’t get your money back until the startup you invested in is sold or goes public.
Startup investments are illiquid. That’s why we recommend allocating only a small amount of your overall portfolio into this asset class.
One Thing We’ll Never Do
After reading about the 3 pitfalls of private investments — what you might have been hoping was the “perfect investment” — you may be feeling discouraged.
But here’s the thing…
We’ll never present you with a problem, without also providing you with a solution!
So, next week, Matt will start telling you how to overcome all the pitfalls I just went over.
As you’ll see, he’ll show you how you could still invest in breakthrough companies — companies that have the potential to hand you 1,000%+ returns:
- Without betting on unproven, risky businesses.
- Without having to wait years for your profits to come in.
- And without locking up your cash in illiquid investments!
In other words, he’ll show you how you could potentially earn big profits — but with much less risk, and in much less time, than with traditional private investing.
So be sure to keep an eye on your inbox next Wednesday at 11:00 AM Eastern!
blocker steps down from FATE
Energy Inspectors Corporation Receives U.S. Environmental Protection Agency National WaterSense Provider of the Year Award For 2020
Chinese President Xi Jinping: Participate in Making Digital Currency and Digital Tax’s International Rule Actively
BIG qualify for BLAST Premier Fall Finals over Complexity
1 p.m. Update: Georgia Power working to restore remaining 68,000 customers after Hurricane Zeta
South Korean Hospitals to Usher in New Healthcare Era Using Blockchain Technology, AI and Big Data
[AWS Certified Developer] – Associate Practice Test Exam
Edward: “After three consecutive tournament victories in 2018, we could have become the best team in the world, but we chose to hang out”
VR Animation Baba Yaga Exclusive to Oculus Quest in 2021
Bitcoin-Themed NFT Card Set Launches On Anniversary Of Satoshi’s White Paper
Verizon’s New Blockchain Verification Tool ‘Full Transparency’ Combats Fake News
9 a.m. Update: Georgia Power working to restore remaining 78,000 customers after Hurricane Zeta
E-Bikes Catch on Outside China, Boosting Global Market Growth Through 2024
Chinese City Eyes Blockchain Applications for Urban Governance and Smart Education
USCYBERCOM Released New Malware Samples
The Bank of Russia Says CBDC Will Eliminate Challenges Caused by Cryptocurrencies
ESEA Season 35 Global Challenge canceled
The WordPress Core Team has Released an Emergency Release of WordPress 5.5.3
Exchange between ChantsWood (Beijing) Information Technology Co., Ltd. and ZHOU Qian, Renowned Chinese Expert on Electric Power Communication
Energy Fuels Announces Q3-2020 Results; Debt-Free with Strong Working Capital; Advancement of Uranium & Rare Earths; Webcast on November 3, 2020
7 p.m. Update: Power restored to nearly 741,000 Georgia Power customers after Hurricane Zeta’s path through Georgia
ACC: Plastic Waste Study In “Science Advances” Provides Incomplete Picture
Complexity eliminate FaZe from BLAST Premier Fall Series
TRAMS DEX Propels Global Adoption of DeFi with Automated Market Maker (AMM) protocol
AI Contact Tracer Awarded at UNLV
Bixin Ventures Announces $100M Proprietary Capital Fund to Support Global Blockchain Ecosystem
SHANGHAI, Oct 26, 2020 – (ACN Newswire)
CB Insights: Trends, Insights & Startups from The Fintech 250
Valarhash Launches New Service Series for its Mining Hosting Operations
Trends, Insights & Startups from The Fintech 250
The VR Game Launch Roundup: Time to Grapple With Zombies & Interior Design
Hackers Continue to Target Zerologon Vulnerability
Oculus Quest 2 Sales Surpass Facebook Expectations, Pre-orders 5x More Than Original Quest
Warning: This Is Cyber Criminals’ New Method of Attack
Current Research on Effect Specific Uses of Cannabis
Friday Charts: I Double Dare You To Ignore This Trend
Five Nights at Freddy’s AR: Special Delivery Update Expands Phone Compatibility, Adds New Modes
Hybrid Tower Defence/FPS Cyberspace VR Launches Kickstarter
How Telemedicine Can Help Keep Your Health on Track
Website Packages – Good or Evil?
Esports1 week ago
How to Play With Friends Online in Dynamax Adventures in Pokémon Sword and Shield The Crown Tundra
Esports1 week ago
How to Separate and Rejoin Calyrex from Glastrier or Spectrier in Pokémon Sword and Shield Crown Tundra
Esports5 days ago
FIFA 21 Global Series: Full List of FGS Swaps 1 Events
Esports1 week ago
How to complete Legendary Clue? 4 and catch Necrozma in Pokémon Sword and Shield’s The Crown Tundra expansion
Esports7 days ago
How to get Electabuzz and Electivire in Pokémon Sword and Shield’s The Crown Tundra expansion
Blockchain5 days ago
Top 10 Blockchain-as-a-Service (BaaS) Providers
Esports1 week ago
How to get Victini in Pokémon Sword and Shield’s The Crown Tundra expansion
Esports7 days ago
Where to Find the Electirizer and Magmarizer in Pokémon Sword and Shield’s The Crown Tundra expansion