One of four men charged with defrauding investors of more than $722 million through a long-running cryptocurrency mining scheme has pleaded guilty to charges against him.
The man, a 35-year-old Romanian programmer called Silviu Catalin Bacali, was arrested in Germany in December 2019. He was charged with one count of a conspiracy to commit wire fraud as well as a conspiracy to offer and sell unregistered securities. He faces a maximum of five years in prison and a fine of $250,000.
Three others — Matthew Brent Goettsche, Russ Albert Medlin, Jobadiah Sinclair Weeks and Joseph Frank Abel — were charged in connection with the scheme in the United States that same month.
Prosecutors allege that the scheme — operational between April 2014 and December 2019 — solicited money from investors in exchange for shares in purported cryptocurrency mining pools. Investors were awarded bonuses for recruiting further investors into the network.
The indictment cites correspondence between Goettsche and Balaci in which they allegedly discussed how to fake mining earnings and referred to their investors as “sheep.”
While the other defendants allegedly offered investors the choice of investing in three separate Bitcoin (BTC) mining pools, Bacali admitted that he himself was unaware that the BitClub Network operated more than one pool.
Further correspondence between the programmer and Goettsche from 2015 apparently revealed that Bacali was asked to “bump up the daily mining earnings starting today by 60%,” which he objected to as being “not sustainable” and “ponzi teritori [sic.]”.
He is nonetheless charged with changing figures to mislead investors at his accomplice’s urging. Bacali has also confirmed prosecutors’ allegation that the scheme fleeced at least $722 million worth of BTC from investors.
Early warning signs
In March 2017, Cointelegraph reported on allegations that BitClub had launched a malleability attack on the Bitcoin network. The scheme had also been flagged as suspicious by crypto media news outlet 99Bitcoins as early as 2016.
Ethereum tumbles by 9% after breaching new all-time high
Ethereum has stolen the limelight from Bitcoin this week, forming a new all-time high of $1,440 while Bitcoin consolidated in a range between $34,000 and $37,000.
However, Ethereum failed to resist against a market-wide sell-off on Wednesday morning, with it plunging by more than 9% to as low as $1,238 before finding a bounce.
The move to the downside coincided with a drop in the price of Bitcoin, which has been attributed to a lack of bullish momentum to the upside.
Whilst investors will be looking on nervously as Ethereum continues its plight to the downside, it remains bullish on all higher time frames and most importantly from a macro perspective.
The recent high of $1,440 marks the fourth consecutive higher high, while there has also been sequential lower highs to the downside, indicating a clear uptrend.
Ethereum will only fall into bearish territory upon a reversal, which would be triggered if it begins closing daily candles below the psychological level of support at $1,000.
This would only happen if Bitcoin continues to lose momentum and tumble below $30,000 and if Ethereum falls back to around 0.03 against its BTC trading pair.
All eyes will be on how Ethereum performs on February 10, as this marks the listing of Ethereum futures on the CME.
While this event is considered by many to be bullish, Bitcoin’s listing on the CME in December 2017 marked the top of the bull market.
What we can expect this time around is a rally in the price of Ethereum moving into the event before a subsequent sell-off in fear that history may repeat itself.
For more news, guides and cryptocurrency analysis, click here.
API3 Review: Building Decentralized APIs for Web 3.0
Decentralized Autonomous Organizations, more commonly called DAOs, are an increasingly common way of providing hands-off governance for blockchain projects, and one of the projects recently in the spotlight is API3.
The project is an ambitious one that is looking to tackle the “Oracle problem” and find a way to connect the various APIs of data providers. The approach of building a decentralized API network (dAPI) is what’s drawn so much attention to the project. It has also been called the “Chainlink Killer” and that name is also bringing a lot of hype to the project.
In the following review we will take a look at the API3 project and how it works, while also discussing its approach to solving the Oracle problem. We will also look at the tokenomics of the project, while discussing the use cases and key features of API3.
What is API3?
In order to get a grasp on the concept of what API3 is doing we first have to understand what the API itself does. The acronym API stands for Application Programming Interface, and it is a well documented protocol that enables the transfer of data and services.
APIs have long been in use by web and mobile applications and programmers are extremely familiar with them. One example of an API is the method that’s used by the various cryptocurrency exchanges to provide data to the aggregators like Coinmarketcap.com.
The API is extremely handy for all types of applications. It’s also been used to monetize data in many cases where data providers allow developers to include their data in an app for a fee. This is quite positive for software development since it is one way for developers to more efficiently build their app without having to create everything themselves. Think of APIs like a Lego set, where developers can choose what they need and then snap it into their applications. Without APIs many applications would fall apart.
While all of this sounds wonderful for application development, there is a problem occurring due to the evolution to dApps and Web 3.0. That problem is the API infrastructure is not compatible with these new technologies. However, API3 is working to make it possible for the older API data providers to connect their data sources to smart contracts without the need for a third-party intermediary. They are accomplishing this through the dAPI decentralized blockchain API network.
Value Proposition of dAPI
Prior to the API3 solution it was thought that oracle technology could provide data to smart contracts as a middleware solution. One of the best known of these is Chainlink. The Chainlink solution has a node that sits between the API provider and the smart contract that requires data. The problem is that this adds a new intermediary to the process, and one of the guiding principles in decentralization is to remove third-party solutions.
One issue with this design is that often an oracle network will be rent-seeking, meaning the cost of everything is continually rising. And since Chainlink has become a dominant oracle network it is also gaining a monopoly over data feeds, which is creating a type of centralization. Additionally, there is no way to govern the data being provided to the oracles. Yes, the nodes are punished for providing bad data, but there’s no penalty enforced on the data provider.
API3 believes the solution is to allow the API providers to run their own nodes. This creates competition that will lower inflation, it promotes decentralization, and it allows a way to actually govern the data providers themselves. With the immense growth of the DeFi economy it is crucial that applications are able to source trustworthy and reliable data. And one way to ensure this is to make the process as transparent as possible.
Under the API3 system each oracle would own their data and the services being provided, making them first-party oracles. This not only increases decentralization, it will also allow the data feeds to be curated transparently, which is an important consideration in DeFi applications.
The Oracle Problem
One of the most well known issues facing smart contracts for years has been the oracle problem. It arises because when you have an on-chain smart contract with enforceable functions and rules it seems very useful. Until you realize that it is only useful with the data already inside the Ethereum network.
As an example from financial markets, there’s no way to make a smart contract on the price of an asset, such as an equity or gold, when the only source of data is off-chain. And there’s the heart of the oracle problem.
How is it possible to get this data on-chain, and how do you do it in a decentralized and trustless manner? And in addition to that how can you protect against an attack on the data source, and verify the truth of the data? When relying on oracles you are increasing the available attack vectors on the smart contract and on the oracle provider.
Ever since smart contracts were developed blockchain engineers have been looking for ways to solve the oracle problem, and they’ve gone at the solution in a number of ways. Some of these, like Augur and Gnosis, use the very circuitous method of prediction markets. But the preferred method has always been an oracle provider that will deliver data anonymously, cost-effectively, and without the need for any third-party intervention.
That’s led to the creation of Chainlink.
Considering the current state of solutions that include oracles we can’t very well discuss the oracle problem without discussing Chainlink. It’s become the most well-known oracle solution, and in the past several years the project has made significant strides in the blockchain industry. They have a large and invested community, and their LINK token is positioning itself to be one of the blue-chip crypto tokens that could stand the test of time.
However all is not perfect with Chainlink. It does have problems. Problems that API3 can solve.
The API Problem
So basically the oracle problem is really just an oversight in the development of smart contracts on the Ethereum network. The development of oracles did not consider the decentralization of the nodes collecting and delivering oracle data. And we shouldn’t overcomplicate the problem by considering that anyone could deliver oracle data, should we?
In reality the problem that oracles solve isn’t as complex as many might have you believe. What oracles are trying to solve, in a fairly complex manner, is simply the ability to pull off-chain data into on-chain smart contracts. In that respect oracles have been compared with APIs used in web and mobile apps since both solutions are used to deliver data to an end consumer.
So, rather than thinking of an oracle as an abstraction of the API, why not just use the actual design philosophy of the API in the blockchain?
Wouldn’t it be better to design an network where you can use an API call to get data rather than paying an oracle several dollars? Even if the oracle cost is brought down to pennies it would be quite expensive over time. And wouldn’t it be good if you actually knew where the data was coming from rather than trusting in a series of anonymous nodes?
Finally, wouldn’t it be great to avoid all the possible attack vectors opened by the use of oracles and just deliver data in a seamless integration without any additional security risks?
That’s exactly what Chainlink can’t do, but what API3 is trying to do.
The API3 Solution
Now that we know all the problems in delivering data on-chain to smart contracts let’s look at how API3 plans on solving the problems more effectively than the current oracle-based solutions.
Basically API3 wants to take all the value that would be passed to the nodes in Chainlink and deliver it to the actual data providers. This gets rid of the middleware. Rather than plopping some nodes in between the data providers and the smart contracts, API3 suggests it would be better to simply make the data providers themselves nodes.
That gets rid of an additional, and unneeded layer and solves a number of the problems that Chainlink is already working against, and others that it will face in the future as it scales.
Consider that the data providers under API3 will now have a reputation to uphold. They are no longer anonymous, but are providing their data directly to consumers, and if that data is flawed it is immediately known and there are repercussions.
In oracle solutions the node is punished, but the data provider can continue providing false data with no penalty. And because nodes in Chainlink are anonymous no one ever knows which node was involved in the bad data either. The API3 solution means that the data providers are directly invested in the process and in the truthfulness of their data.
The API3 solution removes the possibility of ‘oracle bribing’ and it’s done so in a most cost effective manner. To be certain Chainlink has also solved the oracle bribing problem, but the solution they’ve used is prohibitively expensive. In order to avoid the possibility of a node being bribed Chainlink has designed its network to use multiple nodes to deliver the true data, but each node is expensive, and using multiple nodes becomes very expensive.
The API3 solution is called Airnode. It is deployable on-chain and it requires very little in the way of onboarding for the API provider. The API3 team is able to assist, making the addition of Airnode easy. And it is a set it and forget it solution, requiring no maintenance on the part of the API provider. The data is there, live on-chain and available to anyone who wishes to call it. There’s no nodes required, no need for incentive costs, and no added attack vectors.
It’s a simple and elegant solution.
How does Airnode Work?
Airnode was developed by API3 on Ethereum’s network. It is an off-chain system that feeds data to an aggregator contract using Ethereum nodes. That aggregator contract is a decentralized API that is callable from other contracts. In essence Airnode is an oracle node, but it is operated by the API providers in an almost frictionless way.
A challenge to decentralized API solutions has been that the API providers are relatively unfamiliar with blockchain architectures and systems, meaning it is extremely difficult to transition them to the operation of oracle nodes. By providing a solution like Airnode, which is basically a wrapper on a traditional Web API, the API providers can easily have their data written to a blockchain.
By allowing API providers to run their own oracles it becomes far easier for them to service blockchain applications and to manage all the metadata that’s needed for reliability and monetization of the data. In the oracle system the top Chainlink node operators have been able to earn as much as $100,000 per month as DeFi becomes increasingly popular.
If those rewards were extended directly to the API providers it could open up a whole new market for the providers, and decreased costs for the applications that use the dAPI data.
An additional benefit of API3 is that is allows a data consumer the option of using on-chain insurance. This insurance protects them from the malfunction of an oracle or API, and compensates data consumers for quantifiable losses. This method provides an incentive for the API3 governing body to maintain integration and data quality, while also allowing a fallback in the event of a technology failure.
API3 Token Use Cases
API3 intends on using a decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) for its governance, which means every participant in the ecosystem will have their own say in the development and security of the network.
As a result the API3 token will have the following use cases:
- Staking: API3 token holders can stake API3 to earn rewards and participate in on-chain governance.
- Governance: There is a direct economic incentive for voting, as stakers receive a portion of dAPI revenue and their staked tokens are collateral for on-chain insurance.
- Collateral: The staking pool will act as collateral for on-chain insurance.
- Payments: There will be a subscription fee for dApps using the dAPI network. Additionally, data providers will receive payment in API3 tokens.
- Disputes: In the case of loss of revenue due to malfunction, downtime, or incorrect data, dApps using will be able to open disputes to raise an insurance claim. The team plans to use Kleros to resolve insurance claims.
Governance, specifically decentralized governance, seems to be a requirement of any blockchain projects these days. API3 has that covered as it plans on following a DAO governance model. That adds to the value of the tokens beyond a simple monetary value.
It means those who own and stake API3 tokens have a say in the governance of the blockchain. They can decide to vote for or against any updates to the fee structure, or other governance changes that could have an impact on their investment in the project. Considering that API3 will be a data marketplace this could be quite powerful, and is a bullish signal for the project.
Included in the governance aspect is a staking mechanic, which not only allows for voting and governance, but also rewards those who are willing to stake their tokens as insurance against data errors or malfunctions in the system.
It would be naïve to think that this won’t happen, but with a good design they should be few and far between. We’ve already seen similar errors occur on other platforms, and it is good to see that API3 is acknowledging this and putting in a solution for the possibility.
The other benefit to staking is that it reduces the circulating supply, which is always good for price.
The API3 Team
API3 was co-founded by three individuals. The team lead is Heikki Vanttinen who led a development team of about 20 members. He is a veteran in the segment of the language machine.
He was joined by Burak Benligiray, a former Google scholar. He is also the former CTO at CLC Group and Honeycomb. According to his own curated online resume he does oracle and vision stuff. He has a passion for smart contracts and bringing cutting-edge technology into real-world use. Previously he has worked at start-ups and provided freelance research consultancy in computer vision and artificial intelligence.
The third co-founder of the project is Saša Milić, who describes herself as a software engineer / data scientist / researcher in the cryptocurrency / blockchain space. Prior to joining API3 she worked in software engineering (both small startups and large tech companies including Facebook), data science in venture capital, research (computational linguistics, cognitive science) and teaching (computer science, data science) in both academia and industry.
The API3 Token
API3 raised $3 million this past November in a private funding round. That was followed by a public sale in December 2020. That public sale raised $23 million and API3 tokens were sold on a bonding curve starting at $0.30 each and going up to $2.00. Since then the token has done very well, returning roughly 1,300% on a USD basis to the early investors.
With a total supply of 100,000,000 API3 tokens there were a total of 30,000,000 sold in the private (10 million) and public (20 million) sales. It’s notable that only the public tokens are unlocked. All the other tokens are subject to either 2-year or 3-year vesting schedules. Tokens are required for staking and governance as well, so the early investment seems to be quite a smart move.
The tokens began trading on December 1, 2020 at $1.30 and immediately began climbing higher. Within a week they were solidly above the $2.00 level. There was a dip back under $2.00 at the end of 2020. The price climbed steadily in early 2021, and jumped sharply in mid-January 2021, basically doubling to a high of $4.70 on January 17, 2021.
That sharp move higher was part of a broader move in all the DeFi linked names at the time, so it’s uncertain if the gains will hold, or if the token will drift back down in the coming weeks.
There’s no doubting that as blockchain usage grows, and developers come up with more novel and complex use cases the dApps created will also need better ways to interface with third-party data sources. The existing oracle solutions are functional, however there have been compromises made in their design that could lead to serious problems as the solutions need to scale.
Data could be compromised, and costs are likely to increase to the point of exclusion. In the case of data compromise or corruption the impacts could be huge as the highly automated nature of smart contracts and dApps could see any data corruption spread throughout the entire network.
The solution from API3 that enables the API providers to operate the Airnode oracle would give us interoperability with third-party services in a decentralized manner. And it will also ensure that the API providers are incentivized to provide trusted, high-quality data.
When you consider the huge returns that node operators in oracle systems have seen it is pretty likely that API providers will be glad to capitalize on their ability to easily provide data and services via the incredibly easy to implement Airnodes.
Unless something superior comes along it appears that API3 is bringing a powerful solution to the problem of connecting traditional API services and decentralized blockchain technology.
It’s certainly too early to determine if API3 will be the solution to the oracle problem, but things do look very promising in these early days. You may want to keep your eyes on this project and see how it develops and grows.
Featured Image via Shutterstock
Disclaimer: These are the writer’s opinions and should not be considered investment advice. Readers should do their own research.
Huobi partners with BCB Group to streamline OTC desk
Seychelles-based cryptocurrency exchange Huobi has partnered with European crypto-focused payment services provider, BCB Group, as it aims to continue globalising its offerings.
The integration with London-based BCB Group will provide Huobi’s clients with fiat on/off ramps as well as the ability so send fiat to crypto counterparties via BLINC, an instant settlement service.
Working with BCB will enable Huobi to bank its OTC desk with the firm as well as let them handle foreign exchange flow.
📢 Excited to announce our partnership with @HuobiGlobal @CiaraHuobi:”Partnering with BCB allows us to offer a European fiat on and off ramping service…it allows our customers in Europe to experience a smooth and hassle-free user experience.”
READ: https://t.co/4ChTbSguQB pic.twitter.com/DFwXkH4IOC
— BCB Group (@BCBcrypto) January 18, 2021
Ciara Sun, the VP and Head of Global Business at Huobi, said: “We understand the importance of both a compliant, and streamlined service.
Partnering with BCB allows us to offer a European fiat on and off ramping service that we know is in line with the laws of that area, but it also allows our customers in Europe to experience a smooth and hassle-free user experience.”
Oliver von Landsberg-Sadie, Founder and CEO of BCB added: “This important partnership furthers BCB’s mission to promote future-friendly growth of the industry. We are excited to play a part in Huobi’s global project.”
For more news, guides and cryptocurrency analysis, click here.
5 Best Bitcoin Alternatives in 2021
Digital money which takes the form of tokens or coins is said to be cryptocurrency. Which some have entered the physical world in different ways, most of the cryptocurrencies remain intangible.
There are more than 2,000 cryptocurrencies but Bitcoin has been a trendsetter, leading in a wave of cryptocurrencies built on a decentralized peer-to-peer network. But the field of cryptocurrencies is always expanding, Bitcoin is not the only big cryptocurrency available, and the next great digital token may be released tomorrow, for all we know.
Last year was the most challenging for our global economy and traditional ways because of the pandemic. With the lockdown and fear of recession, more of the institutional investors took a step towards cryptocurrencies as a savior against the major economic threats. Hence this year, 2021, seems the best for cryptocurrency investment. But not only in Bitcoin. So here we bring to you the best Bitcoin alternatives to invest in 2021.
1. Ethereum (ETH)
Defi (decentralized finance) is one of the fastest-growing trends in the cryptocurrency world. It transforms insurance, loans, etc., and makes them independent from centralized financial institutions. Ethereum, the second-largest cryptocurrency after Bitcoin, is the best choice for getting into Defi.
Ethereum is the best cryptocurrency to invest in 2021 because it was one of the outstanding performers in 2020. It has a market capitalization of $68,127bn.
Ethereum is a decentralized software, open-source blockchain network without any third party interruption. It’s the best option for decentralized apps (dApps). In addition to its own cryptocurrency named Ether (ETH), the Ethereum software also supports other crypto currents that are also active in the decentralized finance sector like Maker (MKR) & Aave (AAVE).
2. Ripple (XRP)
Launched in 2012, now the third-largest cryptocurrency, Ripple is an alternative financial payments system that offers 100% safe, instant, certain, and low-cost international payments. Its blockchain has expanded to more than 40 countries. With its unique consensus ledger, which doesn’t require mining, and other special features, Ripple sets itself apart from other Bitcoin and altcoins. With growing support from different banks and commissions like HDFC Bank Limited, the Bank of America, the European Commission, etc., Ripple seems to be a great choice for investors since its future looks bright.
3. Litecoin (LTC)
Launched in 2011, Litecoin is pretty affordable among the options. It’s based on an open-source global payment network that is not controlled by any central authority and uses “script” as a proof of work, which can be decoded with the help of CPUs of consumer-grade.
Litecoin is pretty similar to Bitcoin but it offers a faster transaction confirmation time because it has a faster block generation rate. Some specialists also believe that its price will increase in the coming years. Hence this time investing in Litecoin can be very fruitful.
4. TRON (TRX)
Tron is a peer to peer, blockchain network whose founders were targeting to revolutionize the entertainment industry and democratize content creation and they got the perfect opportunity in 2020. Tron works as a content sharing platform on which users create or share their content to get rewarded with TRX, without a middleman. It also has a bunch of great partnerships like Samsung, oBike, etc. Tron Foundation has been in some controversies recently because of its founder Justin Sun but it’s a great cryptocurrency to invest in right now because it’s growing continuously.
5. Binance Coin (BNB)
Binance Coin, the official token of the Binance cryptocurrency exchange platform, is a decentralized platform where users can buy and sell Binance coins but can also use BNB to convert other cryptocurrencies from one to another. It was originally hosted on Ethereum until Binance decentralized exchange (DEX) went online in 2017 with a different mission.
Founded in 2017, Binance DEX has become one of the biggest cryptocurrency exchange platforms which has helped with the popularity of digital assets. It also lets users pay for some goods and services and offers a discount to users who pay transaction fees on the exchange with BNB. It’s a good time to invest in BNB right now because it’s gaining popularity and for all, we know it could be the most famous one soon.
It’s only a matter of time before cryptocurrencies and crypto payments are adopted as a whole. After all, 2021 is going to be one of the greatest years for the entirety of the crypto market.
Invest in these cryptocurrencies other than Bitcoin and take advantage of this situation before it’s too late.
Source: “Jeremy Collins is a Chicago University graduate who has been working in advertising for the last ten years. He is an expert designing and marketing specialist in most social media platforms including Facebook and has been working with the forum ever since it starts years ago.”
Tesla Model 3 and Model Y’s adjustable suspension hinted anew in Owner’s Manual update
Designer DNA molecule helps hunt down cancer stem cells in blood
User Acquisition：the low-cost strategies every advertiser should know
Unique magic mushroom microdosing study to begin in Australia
Computer algorithm spots endangered wildlife in satellite images
88-megawatt Canadian hydro-to-hydrogen plant to open in 2023
Tesla’s permits for Giga Berlin’s battery plant still pending despite hiring ramp
Queen’s Gambit Expands Blank-Check IPO to $300 Million
Take a Ride With Helicopter SPAC Experience Investment
Webinar: A New ETF Strategy for the SPAC Surge
New SEC Chair Gary Gensler Could Push For SPAC Regulation
Exercise hormone injections boost fitness in even old or unhealthy mice
Nissan electric camper van concept is a backcountry ski hut on wheels
Jellyfish-inspired robot moves like nature’s most efficient swimmer
Tesla registrations in California in Q4 jump as Model Y shines in home state
Breakthrough study finds age-related cognitive decline may be reversible
Biden recommits U.S. to Paris climate accord, blocks Keystone pipeline
Payments Startup Payoneer in Merger Talks With SPAC
Acamar Partners Acquisition Corporation (ACAM) Shareholders Approve CarLotz Deal
Glaciers on Mars likely didn’t form during a single ice age event
Alliant Energy donates community solar for local Habitat for Humanity families
Critical Cisco SD-WAN Bugs Allow RCE Attacks
Court strikes down Trump emission policy on his final day in office
Volkswagen ends Golf production for U.S. to make way for electric ID. series
NVIDIA Gamers Face DoS, Data Loss from Shield TV Bugs
Michael Moe, fresh from raising $225M for education-focused SPAC, set for another free Startup Bootcamp
Intel Chairman Gets Medtronic Backing for $750 Million SPAC IPO
Goldman CEO Says SPAC Explosion ‘Unsustainable’
Scientists synthetize new material for high-performance supercapacitors
Tesla bear Jim Chanos isn’t shorting $TSLA anymore, he’s moved to a Put position
Amb Crypto6 days ago
Ethereum, Dogecoin, Maker Price Analysis: 15 January
Blockchain1 week ago
Bitcoin, Altcoins Dip. Are Crypto Entering Bear Territory?
Amb Crypto6 days ago
How are Chainlink’s whales propping up its price?
Gaming1 week ago
CD Projekt RED Could be Fined 10% of its Annual Income by Polish Government if Cyberpunk 2077 Patches Don’t Fix the Game
Amb Crypto6 days ago
NavCoin releases its new privacy protocol, one day after Binance adds NAV to its staking program
SPAC Insiders1 week ago
Churchill Capital Corporation IV (CCIV) Reportedly in Talks for Merger with Lucid Motors
Blockchain1 week ago
2.5 Crore INR Scam: Pluto Exchange CEO Arrested in India
Gaming1 week ago
Cyberpunk 2077 Support To Be Monitored by Polish Consumer Protection Agency
Blockchain6 days ago
Warp Finance Relaunches With ‘Additional Security’ from Chainlink
Blockchain6 days ago
Litecoin Regains Footing After Being Knocked Back by Resistance
Gaming1 week ago
Xbox Series S Specs Will be Adequate for Graphically Intensive Next-Gen Games, Super Meat Boy Forever Dev Believes
Gaming1 week ago
10 Best Speedruns from AGDQ 2021